Warren Watson
First Thoughts
May 29, 2008
Principals and the First Amendment
High school principals appear to have become more rigid in their attitudes about the First Amendment and other student expression issues, according to a new study that we are completing at the J-Ideas project at Ball State University.
In the last months, we have surveyed 125 high school principals nationwide to gauge their attitudes about the First Amendment. The study is a replication of similar work done in 2004 by University of Connecticut researchers Ken Dautrich and David Yalof. We’ll be publishing our results soon.
A preview:
· 77 percent of high school principals believe that students should not be allowed to publish controversial stories in their student newspapers without the approval of school officials. That’s up from 75 percent in 2004.
· 29 percent of those surveyed strongly disagreed that the First Amendment goes too far in the rights it guarantees. In 2004, 52 percent strongly disagreed.
· 47 percent said schools were doing a good or excellent job in teaching the First Amendment. That number slipped from 62 percent in 2004.
“Not much has changed,” said Steve Hirt, principal at North Monterey High School in California. “It’s not as much of a priority when it compares to school test scores, safety and security.”
Principals interviewed also said they understood why some attitudes seemed to have slipped. Fear of litigation and a concern that students have lost a sense of civility were cited as two of the reasons.
Stay tuned for more on the study. |